PASCACK VALLEY—In November 1901, the people of Hillsdale and Woodcliff (the “Lake” part of the name came later) were thoroughly spooked. It was the season for hunting raccoons and trapping muskrats, but people were staying out of the forests and fields. Word around town was that there was a ghost afoot. The reports made it into the New York newspapers.
“George Ellen, while returning from a visit to his sweetheart last night, says he was accosted by the ghost and that it followed him,” wrote the New York Tribune on Nov. 20, 1901. “Other people have reported seeing the ghost, and, as there are no young people in the neighborhood of its haunts, the victims say they have not been joked.”
Some said the ghost was that of an old farmer whose body had been found in his field near the Hillsdale-Woodcliff border in 1899.
One of the men who claimed to have seen the apparition was Caesar Snyder, who worked as a driver at Gardenier’s livery stable. The stable was located in the center of Hillsdale, where the Bank of America building is now standing next to the park.
He told newspaper reporters that he and his brother, Alfred, were walking near Hillsdale when they saw a white object that at first appeared to be about the size of a cat. Caesar said as it approached it grew to the size of a man. They watched as it glided along a road and then disappeared over a fence.
Constable Bert Rawson believed a practical joker was at work, and he was determined to catch them.
“Rawson, with some of his companions, have decided to arm themselves with shotguns and watch nightly. Should they meet the ghost, they will first command a halt, and if this is not heeded, they will blaze away at it with their shotguns,” the Brooklyn Daily Eagle reported.
Just three days later, Pascack’s ghost mystery was solved. A search party did indeed keep watch for several nights on the road between Hillsdale and Woodcliff—and it’s a good thing they didn’t shoot.
The specter turned out to be an old man who was an employee at the Hillsdale House, a hotel located at Broadway and Hillsdale Avenue, opposite the train station.
The man in question, who had a long white beard and typically sported white overalls and a white cap, would take a shortcut through the woods on the way between Woodcliff and Hillsdale. In doing so, he passed behind a board fence. From the opposite side of the fence (the point of view of the Snyders and others), only the man’s cap and whiskers were visible gliding over the top. Thus, the witnesses concluded that they had seen a ghost cat, which then—upon passing by the fence—shockingly transformed into a full-grown man.
The Rockland County Journal wrote, “It is fortunate that the owner of the white whiskers did not meet Constable Rawson, who had threatened to empty his shotgun at the spook the first time he saw him.”
