Data center dispute lands on March hearing

A developer’s site plan shows a proposed nearly 322,000-square-foot data center at left, an electrical substation near the center and 50 affordable housing units in two buildings at right on the former KPMG property along Chestnut Ridge Road in Montvale. A Nov. 18 court hearing will address the amended affordable housing agreement that includes the data center option; separate site-plan approval would still be required.
A developer’s site plan shows a proposed nearly 322,000-square-foot data center at left, an electrical substation near the center and 50 affordable housing units in two buildings at right on the former KPMG property along Chestnut Ridge Road in Montvale. A Nov. 18 court hearing will address the amended affordable housing agreement that includes the data center option; separate site-plan approval would still be required.

MONTVALE, N.J.—A Bergen County Superior Court judge set the week of March 8, 2027, for hearings on Montvale’s disputed fourth-round affordable housing plan amendment, which allows a developer to construct a 322,000-square-foot data center and 50 affordable housing units instead of a 250-unit residential complex, including 50 affordable units, on former KPMG property.

Fair Share Housing Center, a not-for-profit advocate for affordable housing based in Cherry Hill, opposes the Montvale amendment to combine a data center with affordable housing, citing potential noise, pollution, and energy and water usage concerns. 

Fair Share contends that allowing a developer to build an enterprise data center with 50 units of affordable housing nearby would set a precedent that is not allowed under the Mount Laurel doctrine and Fair Housing Act.

Following a nearly three-hour hearing before Judge Lina Corriston on Nov. 18 in Superior Court in Hackensack, attorneys representing Montvale, S. Hekemian Group and Fair Share Housing Center agreed to continue the proceedings at what will likely be a multiday hearing starting next March.

The developer, H&R Montvale LLC, a partnership of S. Hekemian Group and Russo Development, has already applied for a zoning permit to construct the data center and received approval from Montvale’s construction official that a data center is allowed in the OR-2 (Office Research) zone.

Mostly, the Nov. 18 hearing was to discuss the scope and motions to be included in a future trial. The judge previously issued a public notice limiting the scope of the Nov. 18 hearing to Montvale’s amendment.

However, attorneys also raised legal and procedural issues before Corriston that she will likely decide in a ruling expected by early December, said a Fair Share Housing Center spokesperson.

“Today’s hearing was an opportunity to explain why Montvale’s agreement with the data center developer sets a troubling precedent,” said Joshua Bauers, director of exclusionary zoning litigation at Fair Share Housing Center, who represented the organization at the hearing.

Bauers added, “The agreement requires Montvale to provide the developer with a PILOT tax break. If the court approves the settlement, it would give the developer the right to sue Montvale to approve the PILOT and every other step needed to move the project forward. In effect, it creates a way for the developer to bypass meaningful public review and secure financial benefits it wouldn’t otherwise be entitled to. That’s a fundamental misuse of New Jersey’s affordable housing process.”

By early afternoon, only hours after the morning hearing ended, Montvale Mayor Mike Ghassali issued an email update to residents.

“Today, the Court heard arguments regarding the proposed data center, our affordable housing agreement, and objections raised by Fair Share Housing Center and AvalonBay. The Court denied all five motions filed by AvalonBay and moved the fairness hearing to March 2027. A new public notice will be issued, without additional objections,” he wrote.

He noted that the court did not make any final decisions on Fair Share’s arguments opposing a data center but decided to hold a future hearing where both sides will present their cases.

“This (upcoming hearing) is important because Fair Share Housing Center had argued that the proposed agreement should be rejected outright, without such a hearing. Montvale remains confident that our amended agreement complies with New Jersey law. We also believe Fair Share Housing Center is trying to reopen issues that have already been addressed during the affordable housing process. We look forward to presenting our case in March and remain committed to protecting Montvale’s interests while meeting our affordable housing obligations,” wrote the mayor.

Bauers said that Fair Share objected to affordable housing being put close to a data center and that Montvale was using the Mount Laurel law to attempt to site a data center next to affordable housing. Also, Bauers accused Montvale of “hijacking the Mount Laurel process” to put in a data center.

Attorney Michael Edwards, representing Montvale, said Fair Share was conducting a “massive sleight of hand” by trying to relitigate issues previously decided by the settlement agreement and Affordable Housing Dispute Resolution Program. At one point, Edwards told Corriston that Montvale was “riding the tide on what the market wants” with data centers, versus a previous market for warehouses. He also opposed Fair Share’s efforts to relitigate housing unit density on the former KPMG site.

Related: “Developer driving data center at former KPMG site,” by Michael Olohan, Nov. 6, 2026.