MONTVALE, N.J.—A judge will hear arguments Nov. 18 on whether Montvale’s fourth-round affordable housing agreement should allow a data center and 50 affordable homes at the former KPMG site in place of a previously proposed 250-unit housing development.
The in-person “fairness hearing” is scheduled for 9 a.m. before Superior Court Judge Lina P. Corriston in Courtroom 332 of the Bergen County Justice Center in Hackensack. The public may attend.
The hearing concerns an amendment to the borough’s affordable housing agreement. It is separate from the developer’s zoning permit application for a nearly 322,000-square-foot data center.
H&R Montvale LLC, a partnership of Russo Development and S. Hekemian Group, previously proposed 250 homes, including 50 affordable units, on the former 34-acre KPMG property. The borough’s amended plan, submitted in December 2025, instead proposed an enterprise data center and 50 affordable homes.
Pascack Press reported Nov. 9 that H&R Montvale had applied for a zoning permit for the data center. The borough’s construction official said the property’s zoning permits data centers and that one already operates on the site.
Fair Share Housing Center, a statewide affordable housing advocacy organization based in Cherry Hill, has opposed the amended plan since it was proposed. The group questions whether the data center provisions belong in an affordable housing settlement and whether the proposed homes would be on a suitable site.
Developer calls amendment fair and reasonable
S. Hekemian Group argues “Only one question is before the Court: is the Amended Agreement fair and reasonable to people in need of affordable housing?” the company wrote in its preliminary statement.
The developer contends that the amended agreement, Montvale’s settlement with another challenger, Over the Hill Holdings, and credits carried over from the previous housing round together provide enough credits to meet the borough’s applicable fourth-round requirements.
It also argues that Fair Share’s efforts to secure more housing on the KPMG site and prevent a data center lack support in state law and relevant court decisions.
Citing a Sept. 3 court order, S. Hekemian Group maintains that the hearing’s scope is narrow: the change between the settlement terms presented to the state’s Affordable Housing Dispute Resolution Program and the finalized agreement. The company says the amendment satisfies the remaining substantive condition concerning the KPMG site.
Fair Share challenges agreement
Fair Share argues that the amendment goes beyond what an affordable housing settlement can approve.
In its opposition brief, the group calls it “an illegal attempt to bypass the normal land use and redevelopment processes to give a developer contractual rights to build a data center which cannot be approved as part of a Mount Laurel settlement.”
Fair Share also contends that the agreement disregards the dispute resolution program’s recommendation that approval be conditioned on removing the data center provisions, eliminating proposed tax incentives and increasing residential density on the KPMG site.
The group objects to a proposed payment-in-lieu-of-taxes agreement, or PILOT, arguing that it should not be approved through the affordable housing dispute resolution process.
Fair Share’s concerns about placing affordable homes beside a data center include potential noise, air pollution from diesel generators, and additional water and energy use. It argues that the proposal fails to meet affordable housing site-suitability standards.
Spokesperson Jag Davies said Fair Share’s submission includes an expert report from urban planner David Kinsey and opposing letters from Food and Water Watch, the state League of Conservation Voters and the New Jersey Environmental Justice Alliance.
Hearing remains scheduled
Fair Share sought a postponement until after the holidays, saying the hearing could take several days. The group argued that Thanksgiving and the annual State League of Municipalities conference could make consecutive hearing dates difficult to schedule and delay a ruling.
No postponement had been granted as of press time.
The parties and others interested in participating were invited to submit briefs or correspondence before the hearing.
Residents can review filings through New Jersey’s eCourts Civil Part system under case number BER-L-000750-25.
